Jump to content
All posts are moderated, so it will take time for your post to appear!
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...
Sign in to follow this  
Sushyvisa

B1/B2 visitor visa denied for parents

Recommended Posts

Hi,

 

i applied for for my parents visitor visa and it got denied. I’m on H4 visa and my husband on H1B is taking care of the expenses 

my parents have commercial crop agriculture and are self sufficient however at the moment can’t fund their trip. We are three daughters: my older sister is a doctor in India married and 2 kids and younger one is also married has a kid and working in London.

 

my parents are traveling only with the genuine intention of tourism and are planning for a maximum of 2 months stay.

 

they were asked the following questions 

have you traveled anywhere before? - no

who lives in USA?- our daughter 

does she work? - no

what do you have for living in here? - agriculture 

they in return handed over the 214b deniel document and denied it

 

i have applied again and they are attending interview again. How do they convince the CO that they do not intend to extend their stay at all?

my parents will never stay beyond 2 months since they love what they do in their home. They have hard earned property and house that they have made with passion. However it was hard to prove it in the interview since they were not asked a question to prove that. How do we go about it?

 

 

Share this post


Link to post

First, I doubt they were asked only the above questions....first time applicants are asked far more questions....so I believe that the interview was different than stated....(many applicants retell an unsuccessful interview by making it sound like the CO was the bad guy, and the most common thing I heard or read is that 'the CO only asked 2 or 3 questions'....baloney...not of first time applicants....that is just nonsense....(I've had some irate relatives call and claim that 'my (relative) was not even asked one single question and were refused the moment they stepped up to the window!!!"...which is about the dumbest thing I've ever heard....no CO, not even the newest or the most skeptical would refuse an applicant without asking a single question....

second, when is your baby due?

third, your 'testimony' that your parents will never stay beyond 2 months is not even close to being believable....you cannot guarantee that stay, and if they can leave for 2 months, why not 6 ? Someone is taking care of something during their absence, so why is that time allegedly limited? One of my favorites is, 'my parents are old and ill, so I have to return in order to take care of them.."..this after the applicant wrote or said they planned to stay six months in the US!!! When asked who would care for their elderly parents during that time,,,the #1 answer was ,' oh, they won't get sick while I am gone!!'....really? The #2 answer was, 'oh, another relative will check on them..'...when asked why then, would the applicant have to return, the most common response was, 'oh, that relative can't look after them for more than 6 months!!'...who believes this stuff and who dreams it up?

There is no guaranteed way of an applicant convince a CO of their true intentions....and every CO with more than 2 weeks of experience knows full well that CBP routinely admits people for six months on B2 visas....so claiming to this audience otherwise is meaningless.

Share this post


Link to post

Yes. They were asked just this. Honestly they had no clue that the visa gets denied and was not so prepared for it

im not sure what do you mean by “when is your baby due”

Yes they will stay only for 2 months. Multiple reasons:

1. It starts raining a lot in the place they live and they need to be there to handle the property damage that can happen. 6 months is never an option for them to stay away from their home. 

2. We have a live-in support who will take care of the property. They will do it only for April and May since their kids have summer holidays. Their school will start in June and they have to get back to their home by then

3. Yes my grandma is old. But by dad has 6 siblings living almost in the same city. She is with one of the child. They are not relatives, but her own children. This is the usual setup and thier trip has not made any changes to this.. they did not talk about her to the CO.

4. I have already booked their round trip. Unfortunately it’s noteven 100% refundable. So they will return. 

5. My daughter has spring break in April and that’s when we had planned to take them around. April was good for us too. The other time she is free was in November and December. However they can’t handle winter and can’t  visit Niagara Falls then. + point no 2

6. Most importantly they don’t intend to stay in the USA since they love thier home. They are not will to make any changes to thier life in any way. 

Yes. I agree a lot of visitors are not real and don’t intend to do it the way it is suppose to have done. But that’s honestly not true with my parents. I genuinely felt our truth will be recognized by the CO and hence booked the tickets. 

Edited by Sushyvisa

Share this post


Link to post

Sorry, I do not buy the so called 'fact that they were asked only 3 questions...total nonsense. Booking tickets does NOT guarantee anyone's return.

As I suspected, there is the story of the live in support who can take care of things, but oddly, just for the same time they wish to visit....hardly  believable...

Where do you work and how old are the children? (questions that were no doubt asked during parents' interview)

Share this post


Link to post

Hi,

I'm here with an update. My parents B2 visa is approved the second time. This time we chose Chennai. This is the default location for my state though inconvenient. The 1st time we chose Mumbai since it’s conveniet to travel.

they were asked multiple questions

This time my parents were a lot relaxed and wished the CO good morning with a smile

CO: good morning

CO: who is in the US?

Parents: our 2nd daughter, grand child and son-in-law

CO : so how may daughters do you have?

parents: 3

CO : sweet.. what do the other 2 do?

My parents explained

CO: can you give your daughter and son-in-law’s visa and passport

parents gave and the set had my sister’s passport copy as well

CO: pointed at my passport and asked if this daughter is in US

Parents: yes

CO: what do you do for living here?

my parents explained and also gave the property document. But CO said she wouldn’t want to see

CO: why are you traveling for just 2 months?

parents explained about the dependency in India and also my dad about his 97 year old mother..

CO: congratulations. Your Visa is approved. 

And yes they are coming here just for tourism. Neither for baby sitting nor to work illegally like lot of people do.

thank you very much

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
×