Jump to content
All posts are moderated, so it will take time for your post to appear!
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...
Hari0861

BCom and MBA Finance RFE for speciality occupation

Recommended Posts

Hi,

I Got RFE for speciality occupation.  My qualification is BCom and MBA Finance my h1b is having job title as Business Systems Analyst. I have 16 years experience(8 Accounting domain+7Year IT as Oracle Apps Consultant).  now my exten is in RFE.  Can some share the details how to fill RFE response, if they are in the same scenario.  Thanks in Advance. 

Hari 

Share this post


Link to post

Your company, or their attorneys should be responding to RFEs, not you. H1b is an employer's petition and dealing with USCIS is their responsibility. 

Share this post


Link to post
6 hours ago, Provence said:

Your company, or their attorneys should be responding to RFEs, not you. H1b is an employer's petition and dealing with USCIS is their responsibility. 

Typically responding to RFE's either company /Attorney now they are depending on us to provide details.  where as I am Bcom and MBA finance and Oracle Apps certifications.  they are asking to write jobs duties related to general bachelor’s degree in computer science or related field.  and asking me to write how your jobs related to computer education.  I have responded back my difficulty and waiting for response.  mean time i am checking if any one faced the same issue.  Please share the details.

 

Share this post


Link to post

1. If your attorney is asking you these, I am certain he has no clue how to respond

2. Certification does not matter 

3. USCIS knows what B.Com and MBA Finance curriculum in India is (unless you can furnish your transcripts of Bachelors in CS subjects)

4. Find something in job duties and prove that only B.com+ MBA Finance person can do it in Oracle Apps, if you are FTE - can your employer provide that in writing ?

It has been trend that USCIS is strictly going by OOH and matching educational background,good luck tying your B.com and Finance studies to IT job duties. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
On 10/5/2018 at 11:16 PM, Leavemessageh1b said:

1. If your attorney is asking you these, I am certain he has no clue how to respond

 

Attorneys have specializations in law, not on various technical job descriptions. 

A B.A. is job role does not necessarily require technical degree. 

OP:

Uscis review agent might be sending rfe by literal interpretation i.e how a B.A. job in IT based on commerce and finance qualifications. But you know that the reality  is typical BA job role requires MBA and technical background rather than software degree..

Share this post


Link to post
4 hours ago, cap-gap said:

Attorneys have specializations in law, not on various technical job descriptions. 

Thank you for clarifying, but employer's attorney who specializes in non-immigrant worker application usually have mix of staff working for them, who does this job and compiled response is finally reviewed by attorney to check if everything asked in RFE is covered. 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post

Hi Everyone,

Thanks for your suggestions and advice's.  Finally my RFE got approved and 2.5 years extension..... .  If any one is in this situation in the same combinations.  Please email their queries to me i can give special advice persoanlly.  how to write RFE responses.

Thanks

Hari

Share this post


Link to post

Hi hari,

 

I got similar RFE on my visa transfer for business analyst position, as 'Beneficiary Qualification'. would appreciate if you can help me to provide the input so that share to my attorney  . 

Thanks

Madhava

 

image.thumb.png.72f753f2ca7fce542f44d924dd78ce69.png

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, Madhava99 said:

Hi hari,

 

I got similar RFE on my visa transfer for business analyst position, as 'Beneficiary Qualification'. would appreciate if you can help me to provide the input so that share to my attorney  . 

Thanks

Madhava

 

As an employer offering a position based on your qualifications, the employer is best suited to provide their attorney with any and all documentation related to the job. An H1b is the employer's petition, and you have no role in responding to the RFE. 

An RFE is the exclusive domain of the employer through their attorney. 

Share this post


Link to post
On 12/21/2018 at 8:33 AM, Hari0861 said:

Hi Everyone,

Thanks for your suggestions and advice's.  Finally my RFE got approved and 2.5 years extension..... .  If any one is in this situation in the same combinations.  Please email their queries to me i can give special advice persoanlly.  how to write RFE responses.

Thanks

Hari

HI Hari,

I got the similar kind of RFE , now my company asking me to provide Letter on Specialty Occupation,  i did my bachelor  in science ( math,physcis & chemistry)t  , not sure what to write in Letter as i dont have any computer degree, could you  advise me

Share this post


Link to post
35 minutes ago, upneja said:

HI Hari,

I got the similar kind of RFE , now my company asking me to provide Letter on Specialty Occupation,  i did my bachelor  in science ( math,physcis & chemistry)t  , not sure what to write in Letter as i dont have any computer degree, could you  advise me

Does your company have a Legal department?  Lawyers respond to RFEs on behalf of the employers they represent, not employees. 

Share this post


Link to post
4 hours ago, upneja said:

HI Hari,

I got the similar kind of RFE , now my company asking me to provide Letter on Specialty Occupation,  i did my bachelor  in science ( math,physcis & chemistry)t  , not sure what to write in Letter as i dont have any computer degree, could you  advise me

The employer and his lawyer have to handle the RFE. You are not involved with it.

Share this post


Link to post
On 12/21/2018 at 9:33 AM, Hari0861 said:

Hi Everyone,

Thanks for your suggestions and advice's.  Finally my RFE got approved and 2.5 years extension..... .  If any one is in this situation in the same combinations.  Please email their queries to me i can give special advice persoanlly.  how to write RFE responses.

Thanks

Hari

 

Edited by sgowgc

Share this post


Link to post

Thanks Hari for offering your help. I am in the same boat MBA from India applied for H1b extension for Business Analyst and got an RFE for Specialty Occupation. Please let me know if you still have enough patience to advise as you may have quite a good number of emails asking for help.

I need help in mapping day to day responsibilities to the education or any related advise.

Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
On 2/2/2019 at 5:12 PM, sgowgc said:

Thanks Hari for offering your help. I am in the same boat MBA from India applied for H1b extension for Business Analyst and got an RFE for Specialty Occupation. Please let me know if you still have enough patience to advise as you may have quite a good number of emails asking for help.

I need help in mapping day to day responsibilities to the education or any related advise.

Thanks.

RFEs have to be handled by company lawyers/Legal, not you. Lawyers deal with USCIS, not employees. 

Share this post


Link to post

Thank you for taking time to advise but as you advised me I too would like to advise my Lawyer/Legal on things that are concerned to me because by the end of the day the impact of the outcome will be more on me than my Company or Lawyer.

Thanks Again.

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×