Peculiar situation: I 94 status, travel while petition is in progress

[guestb]

Situation:

 

Old petition : valid till Nov 2014

Visa : valid till Nov 2014

 

Travelled outside US : Aug 5, 2014

new petition issued : Aug 15, 2014

travelled back to US : Aug 30, 2014

Admitted till : Nov 2014

I 94 online : Nov 2014

 

new petition which was issued on Aug 15, 2014 while I was outside US, is valid from Nov 2014 to Aug 2016.

 

I want to know which I94 is correct or controlling my status? I94 online or I94 from new petition?